Thursday, July 14, 2005

Political Community Service

I'm posting to start a conversation of how best for the LCYDs to use their time and resources to better our community while maximizing our political effect. I am just finishing my year of being and Americorps*/VISTA in Tallahassee with the Community Neighborhood Renaissance Partnership (www.tallpartners.org), a fantastic nonprofit, but I've seen the good and unfortunate sides of dogoodery. My comments below are based primarily on how I perceive to avoid the unfortunate and make sure we're participating with the good, and I welcome others to ask any questions they have to further the conversation.


What should we be working on?
Several good ideas have already been mentioned towards this end. Maintaining/ preserving/ creating a healthy environment, fighting poverty, promoting education, and preserving family. All of these are excellent, and I'm sure we can think of more.

What are the problems resulting from these issues and why are these bad?
This question allows us to focus on what is wrong, and how something different (spurred by more Democrats in office) would be better. How does cutting down a tree or destroying a wetland effect the environment? What are horrendous correlations to life in poverty? Why is it important for children to have adults around who care about them? It's important at this stage to develop measures for your issue, carbon dioxide levels, crime rates, unwanted pregnancies, juvenile delinquency, recidivism etc. These become the things we can actually measure progress by.

(the following two questions I think are valuable and interesting, but not absolutely necessary)
What does the government do to deal with these problems?
What, especially monetarily, is the government investing in such things as water treatment, police, correctional facilities, etc.

What does the government do to correct these problems?
What programs are in place to actually lower crime rates, etc. Do they work?

What actions work to correct these problems?
By knowing this, we'll have a good understanding of what we should be advocating that the government do, as well as what we should be investing our time working on in the nonprofit sector until the government cowboys up to fund it properly. Good nonprofits evaluate their programs for grants, etc. to show the impact they are having. We should only work with these. If there is a nonprofit that we agree with, and believe their programs have a positive effect but they have not had the resources to evaluate it, our best use of resources would be to help them evaluate their programs.

How best can we help the organizations that are correcting these problems?
After fully grasping the situation we're dealing with, we should balance being visible with being maximally helpful. For instance, many times Habitat For Humanity has more building volunteers than they can use, but they can't use the building volunteers because noone is volunteering to do the filing and other indirect work needed. Obviously direct service with an organization would be the best for our visibility, but we should also be willing to work to build the capacity for us and others to participate in the direct service.

By having a full understanding of why we're volunteering, and working with organizations that know the impact it will have, we will give ourselves strong footing to raise awareness about the issues, advocate real solutions, and candidates who can make those solutions a reality. Thank you for your time.

1 Comment:

Anonymous said...

I think that Ross does make a good point regarding our community service projects. I use to do most of my community service through a service-learning model. Where before you do the service you have brief discussion on why the service that we are doing is important. So if we were to work with Big Bend Cares, the local HIV/AIDS Service Organization, we could have them do a brief presentation before the service or at one of our meetings about what their services are and how HIV/AIDS affects the local area. Then when we worked with them we would know more about what we are working with, and when we shared with our friends all the great times we are having with the LCYDs, especially with service, we can actually share why what we did is important and what we learned.

The other aspect that I think we should consider incorporating into our service projects is time for reflection. After every service project we could have a time of reflection, where we discuss what we learned, what we got out of the service, the positive parts and the parts that we might want to change for the future. It is interesting to hear what different people get out of service, each person brings their own experiences and interpretations to everything. You would probably be surprised what different people get out of the same task, and it might help you look at things differently in the future too.